Obama; The Next Winner of American Idol
75
If you are one of the 4 remaining people in the universe who has never seen American Idol or know the premise of the show, here's a quick review. It's one of America's most popular reality tv shows aimed at finding true singing talent. More people become invested in the contestants and voting on this show than in the United States presidential election. Of course it is aired worldwide so that's not a fair statement, concerning numbers, but just as people in other countries are voting on American Idol, so are people from other countries within U.S. voting in our presidential election.
First, I want to establish a popularity theme here between American Idol and the election of Obama. For example, try looking up "American Idol" on the online source, Wikipedia, and you will encounter as many pages of information there as you will if you look up "Obama". How did anyone besides Obama stand a chance to win against a celebrity like him. Constant commercials with A-list celebs like Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore, even Oprah (the most influential woman in America) were enthusiastically telling us how to vote. Making it a "cool" thing to vote, but forgetting the part to make your decision based on your best knowledge.
Some similarities between the way America voted President Obama into office and voted for their favorite Idol contestant are scary. You see, the judges in American Idol are not looking for the best singer, sounds retarded right? It's a singing contest right? WRONG. The judges look for marketability. For instance, do they have "the look", are they charasmatic- do people like them? Are they confident? Are they different and stand out? Do they have style? Will people vote for them? Do they have a good story? I just listed close to ten factors considered above and besides a great singing voice. And it still is a singing competition right?
I won't justify anything here or get into the nitty gritty of politics or Democrats vs. Republicans vs. Independents vs. Leave me alone I'm not voting, don't like any candidates, don't care Party. American Idol and Obama's election are arguably both popularity contests. What gives me the credentials to identify a popularity contest? I went to high school. But I won't be fooled, If I watch American Idol, I vote for the best singer, not the prettiest or who has the best story. Everybody who voted for Obama is familiar with popularity contests because he ran for one; President of the United States. Many teens currently too young to vote are voting on Amercian Idol and in the future will be voting for President the only way they know how- by popular demand.
I should be happy so many people who have never voted before, voted for Obama. Am I also happy those people voted like they were voting on American Idol with the notion "Oh I like him. I don't know why there's just something about him". Voting off a feeling or because it's about time we have a black president is irresponsible. Please America, admit you voted for Obama because he smokes the cool brand of cigarettes, him and his wife have great style of clothing, and his story and charisma were mesmerizing. He was different than the other candidates, he wasn't the best option, but he was marketable. His popularity caught on like a raging wildfire in California and soon we wanted to know everything about HIM, and nothing about the important stuff. Was he qualified? That's like asking if the best singers win American idol- NOPE.
After the contest, American Idol winners are seldom the ones to go on and make huge hits and become stars- yes some have, but very rare. It's usually the talented good singers who were voted off weeks before the end that end up making albums to become hits. So if America doesn't vote for the best singers in a singing competition then somehow you expect and believe the majorty presidential votes were for the best candidate and not for any other silly reasons that clouded our better judgment at the time?
In fact, you can compare Obama's election to any reality tv show winner. Survivor, the original reality tv show- winners are known to be the most sly, make their own rules, charasmatic yet backstab you while smiling to your face. I just want to bring to attention the factors in which we consider when voting, more importantly voting for our president. I believe we did not vote for the most qualified, talented candidate, and it shows. Nobody is expecting perfection from him, just like even the best singer fails to hit some notes periodically, but I am certain we considered far too much of the other stuff when voting for him. Perhaps he was the right person, but for a different contest. Let him sink or swim on Survivor.
If you're like me and watch various reality tv shows and week after week you are out of your mind about the voting results "How can so many stupid people even know how to vote in the first place?", "Are they watching the same show?". You'll begin to understand what I mean about trying desperately to understand why the majority vote went to Obama. Just because everybody else is doing it, doesn't make it right.
Simon Says...
So you don't like what I've said so far, well it is peaches n' cream compared to what Simon Cowell has said during his career as a judge on American Idol.This is a special little section, and tribute, to the most hated, most loved, most honest, Simon Cowell.
If Simon were judging Obama on American Idol, he'd give him credit for being confident, but since Obama is more cocky than confident, Simon hates cocky so he'll get some of the following remarks: Please note: these are actual Simon quotes said on American Idol, but I've made them relevant to Obama's election.
- "If you've got a big mouth, you're going to get attention"
- "I think you have to judge everything based on your personal taste. And if that means being critical, so be it. I hate political correctness. I absolutely loathe it.”
- "I never want to hear that again, I hate it, I'm allergic to it"!
- “You're useless, I'm bored.”
- "I think you are ignoring the audience who put you there."
- "If you're lifeguard duties were as good as your singing, a lot of people will drown."
- "My advice to you if you want to pursue a career in the business, don't".
So take it or leave it- funny or pathetic, this is all just meant to make you really consider the next president carefully- ask him the tough questions that really matter to the competition. Vote only for his capabilities to lead our country in our (the American people) best interest.
Suggested Reading for your Political Entertainment
- "America Haters" and your next President
The Problem The Solution Note: My Hub rating dropped 4 points when I published this hub. Either it's no good or they don't like what I have to say. You be the judge. jim aka TMWNP Ladies and gentlemen...
CommentsLoading...
This is a great, true and sad analogy; the presidential election was a popularity contest and the choices were all poor and some worse than others. We have the same dilema now in California about the next governor and no matter who gets elected we are scrwed.
I agree that the voters have little knowledge about the issues and get influenced by the media (sheep mentality at its worst), but without decent political candidates we are better off watching and voting for the "American idol"
Great hub! Entertaining and true. Obama was elected because he won the popularity contest. Hopefully in 2012, the American voters will realize their mistake and put someone in office who has some experience not just charisma.
Terrific hub and analogy. If Americans voted intelligently Obama would still be in Chicago. Everything you never wanted in a President was known before the election and yet the American people foolishly put him in the White House. When will experience and integrity start to matter?
IZ ,
like David stone do not watch American Idol, i understand the concept- the best "packaged" contestant wins the prize aside from Kelly Clarkson I could not name another winner why? I think she is a good singer- after the contest- wait there was what Clay Aiken???
I watch the soup so i know about him, Taylor Swift? she's hot did she win?I don't watch Survivor the biggesrt looney or whatever? I do not understand reality shows- i should Do a hub on that... thanks for the idea.... As for obama he is just sad Some of us knew he was a slithering snake that will destroy our country if he gets the chance-which he is doing. Unfortunately- I live in one of the bluest of blue states NY so change in this state will be nearly impossible here. great hub- well done- hopefully we can get a super star for the people in 2012. Winning the elections along the way.
TH
Awesome! Nail on the head! People should be required to know what they are voting on and who they are voting for and what they stand for. Don't know how this could be accomplished, but it would have avoided this big mistake we now have in office.
What a cool and unique analogy Laura. I agree with you and I was handeling something in one of my comments sections yesterday, (I had to as you haven't been stopping in to handle my agitators lately, hint, hint) Anyway, I was telling them that I thought Obama's bigest problem is the poor decisions he's made in who he's surrounded himself with.
I'm putting together another political hub I think it's going to be called "We Elected These Guys?" It's pics of all the convicted felons in Congress and their crime discriptions. Of course I'll tie it into my theme of how criminals leading the country just might have something to do with the sad state of affairs we're in today. and maybe we ought to scrutinize who we vote for a bit more.
This was a very well put together Laura. Thumbs up, useful, and awesome!
jim
An interesting take on the American public and pretty much how all decisions are made when there is voting involved. Who has the fattest pockets to whose bumper sticker will look great on my car. While I did not fall all the way in love with Sarah Palin, what I did like was she had a different voice. That is what I want in a politician. Someone to stand up for me, not someone interested in "smoking the cool cigarettes"..It is refreshing to see so many other people with similar opinions. Sometimes I think I live in a world of robots where no one can think for themselves. Yet another great reason to join this great community. Thanks again!
I haven't watched every season of American Idol, but I've learned more about it within the last two seasons. Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Jordin Sparks, David Cook and Kris Allen were all winners who went on to successful singing careers. And the other winners weren't exactly nobodies either, they just haven't been as widely known. (Although I admit I'm biased towards Kris Allen because I liked the way he sang.) But anyway, American Idol usually gets a top 5 that is all good singers and at that point it doesn't really matter who wins, they will all probably go on to do something. That isn't to say it's not a popularity contest, because that's exactly what it is. However I'm less offended by American Idol's results than I am America's got Talent. That show is supposed to be about a variety of talent but a singer always wins (usually one with a sob story). So I understand your frustration with reality shows.
As for politics, the system is unquestionably broken. Voting is stilted if not downright misleading. I had a heck of a time just seeing what was on my ballot before election day (how can we be informed if we aren't allowed to see what's on the ballot?) And the two party system is only further dividing America. Not only does it give voters an excuse not to read/learn about their candidates (voting a straight ticket) but it seems like there is no compromise between parties in congress. I fear for the next two years because after the 2010 elections, a republican house and a democratic senate will not be able to pass ANYTHING! Senators still get paid, so the ones who suffer from this divide is the American people.
Both the 2008 and 2010 elections were popularity contests (every election is). It's all about who has the most money, who shouts the loudest, and who insults their opponent first. Obama rode a tidal wave of anger towards the republican party (after Bush) to put him in the white house. And the republicans rode a tidal wave of frustration at Obama for not doing things fast enough. Doesn't anyone see a problem here? Going back and forth isn't the solution. How do we know the republicans won't cause another recession and how do we know democrats won't just sit on their hands and not have the guts to make a difference? I don't have any problems with Obama; he has good ideas. The problem is that even with a democratic super-majority, congress barely squeaked by fixes to heath care, wall street and education. Fixing these broken aspects of our country should have been a no-brainer. Each party should have been scrambling to put in their ideas and vote it through, but that's not what happened. Instead it was a long winded debate that left us with a watered down version of what we should have had.
But now I'm ranting and my comment is super long (sorry). The election system is definitely broken, but there are two big things working against us; the first is that most Americans don't want to research all their candidates, and even if they do, it's not easy to dig through all the talking points and political jargon. The second is that we live in a country where money is power and those with money like the broken system (it works in their favor), so we may not see a better system in our lifetime.
The whole electing of a President has come down the almighty dollar. Obama set a new "high" bar on the buying of the US Presidency. 700 million plus for a $400K a year job. The biggest con job ever perpetrated on the American electorate will be his lasting legacy.
Run Donald Trump Run!
Excellent writing and comparison....so true!!! You hit the nail on the head with this piece...it is sad that people vote for a President the same way they vote for a reality TV candidate but its true.....Obama was the flavor of the moment


















David Stone Level 1 Commenter 21 months ago
As one of the four people who has never seen American Idol or any other reality show, I don't know if your analogy is right or not, but I pretty much agree on your analysis of American voters. I've said for a long time that, rather than too few, too many people vote. They vote because they think it's the right thing to do without also concluding that knowing the issues is also the right thing to do. Americans vote for the most recent commercial, talk radio slant or print article that hits their hot button–which is usually the economy, even if they know next to nothing about economics.
As a separate note, I'll add that President Obama has done better than I expected and has achieved some remarkable successes, although not the economic ones everyone is itching for. He can be faulted for playing the "hope' card through the campaign, while he was certainly smart enough to know it was a tactic and a chimera he would have to deal with down the road. When you play the election just to win, sometimes you end up some expectations that you might actually have to pay off on "hope" in a country where everybody seems to think they can sit like slugs in front of TVs for four to six hours a day and let Big Daddy solve all their problems.